Brendan Nyhan

Obama v. Allen?

From the troubling counterfactual department: What if George Allen was the presumptive GOP nominee right now? Many Republicans have lamented that he would have been the candidate with the greatest appeal to the different wings of the party. But he also has an ugly history on racial issues that could have made a general election race against Barack Obama incredibly ugly. (By contrast, with McCain as the Republican candidate, the racial issue is seemingly off the table.)