Brendan Nyhan

Howard Dean: A little too much “straight talk”

Martha Burk notes the apparent influence of George Lakoff on Howard Dean’s language during last week’s “Meet the Press.” But she doesn’t discuss my favorite part — Dean’s unintentionally revealing slip:

Absolutely. I’m not advocating we change our position. I believe that a woman has a right to make up her own mind about what kind of health care she gets, and I think Democrats believe that in general. Here’s the problem–and we were outmanipulated by the Republicans; there’s no question about it. We have been forced into the idea of “We’re going to defend abortion.” I don’t know anybody who thinks abortion is a good thing. I don’t know anybody in either party who is pro-abortion.

Lakoff-style framing is not a solution to the Democrats’ problems (see here and here), but it especially doesn’t work when you admit that you’re trying to manipulate people. It sounds like a NPR game show: “Wait, wait, don’t outmanipulate me!”