Brendan Nyhan

Juvenile Democratic candidate narratives

Try to believe Newsweek pays Howard Fineman to write drivel like this (via Kevin Drum):

You knew Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama in high school. At least I did. They were candidates in the student senate election. She was the worthy but puffed-up Miss Perfect, all poodle skirts and multicolored binders clutched to her chest. He was the lanky, mysterious transfer student—from Hawaii by way of Indonesia no less—who Knew Things and was way too cool to carry more than one book at a time. Who would be leader of the pack?

Presidential elections are high school writ large, of course, and that is especially true when, as now, much of the early nomination race is based in the U.S. Capitol. It is even more the case when the party in question, and here we are talking about the Democrats, is not sharply divided ideologically. They have a good chance in ’08 to oust the fading prep/jock/ROTC/Up With People alliance.

Actually, presidential elections aren’t high school writ large; they just appear that way when idiotic political writers reduce the candidates to caricatures and frame the election as a popularity contest between them.